2014年11月29日 星期六

How Does Codependency Works with the Female’s Quality of Taiwanese Women

     “Codependency” is a mental sickness that acknowledged by psychology which consists of the following characteristics: depending highly on others, viewing personal values low, highly oppressing self-emotion and lacking of independence and a healthy relationship between others (Shu & Wu, 2004). Such characteristics can be strongly associated with the qualities that Taiwanese society usually expected on women, or even those women expected on themselves, such as obedient, passively, taking care of others, etc. As a result, researchers compare the ideas of codependency with women’s qualities above and try to discuss the coherence between the two and whether if our society tends to put sickness on the women with those qualities.
     In the research of department of Educational Psychology and Counseling in National Taiwan Normal University, they divided those women who are tested into four groups of sex character tendencies, which are having the qualities of female, male, both sides and neither. They pick of the tendency of female character and tested them with questionnaire so as to find out their intersection with the quality of codependency. According to the result of the experiment, in the four index of the qualities of codependency, which includes “seeing others as the focus point of life,” “endorsing the character of taking care of others,” “seeking values of life from relationship with others” and “lacking the ability of expressing emotion,” there are only two of the qualities that overlap with the women who tend to be more like a character of women. The two intersections are “endorsing the character of taking care of others” and “seeking values of life from relationship with others.” The other two qualities, however, are present even an opposite rate of the women’s qualities, that is, the more tendency to be like a woman, the less do they “seeing others as the focus point of life” and “lacking the ability of expressing emotion.”
     Whether if codependency can be equalized with women’s qualities under such result are remain question, however, we can find something worth discussing from them. For example, endorsing the character of taking care of others reflect a common notion in Taiwanese society, which is that in Chinese culture, we are used to value helping others as a great virtue, and especially demands highly on women to take care of others, family for instance (Shu & Wu, 2004.) However, it also presents women’s approval to themselves through taking care of others. In other words, we should not see this quality of codependency as a mental sickness, or negative characteristic, on women. Oppositely, we should consider it a behavior for women to exercise their autonomy, just as they decide to make any decision as well.
     Back to Taiwanese society nowadays, influencing by the value of self-improving from the Western culture, we tend to view more valuable on those women who aim to get success as men and consider them as index of improvement. However, we should not neglect those quality of seeing others important, as those are also approvals for some part of women. To sum up, we can say that autonomy for women is not only choose to get the equal status as men, but makes whatever decision by own mind.

Reference
Yi-jen, Shu. & Li-jiaun, Wu. (2004, Sep). Study of Relationships among Sex-role Orientation, Codependency and Self-esteem of Female Adults in Taiwan. Bulletin of Educational Psychology, 36(1) pp.85-107

Retrieved from http://ir.lib.ntnu.edu.tw/ir/retrieve/19448/ntnulib_ja_A0201_3601_085.pdf

2014年11月13日 星期四

Reflection(1)

     During the conference with professor, we have discussion on my topic of whether if I should keep focus on the change of politic in Iran and religion taboo of Islam, for that it seems too tough and complicated to me because of lacking the correct and objective notion about the international affair and history, also, it is kind of difficult for me to have a totally knowledge about Islam unless I read the Quran by myself in the original language. Also, my previous two annotations are commented as “too vague in topic or issue.” The reason why I received such comments may be that I just cannot see the point why I choose the women’s topic in Islam at the beginning, including what influence me about women’s problem in my growth, what do I really care of them and why. The responses from peers also have familiar opinions, that what the things I truly like to discuss is unclear, whether I would like to define whether it is good or bad that women in Iran have to live under strict Islamic rule, or if I want to fight for their right, or something else. There are also opinions about that it is too narrow to simply mention the problem of women’s right in Islam. Those responses also make me to think further of my topic.
     After the meeting with professor, and also consulting the responses from several peers, I decided to connect and compare with Taiwanese women’s situation and predicament in the present time. Writing about Taiwanese women seems to be more close to our society and my own condition. In short, I will keep focus on the topic of women, compare what are the differences and same portions, no matter on which aspects, such as family or work or traditional practices, between the two seemingly far and different cultures, and what are the reactions from each cultures women or others, and finally, what are the possible resolution.
     In the aspect of resources, I will consider to take on some interview of Taiwanese or Islam women, or women who are Islam in Taiwan, and ask about their opinions. Also, it is likely to talk with other opinion from some experts and professors. Resources from Internet are also available, and I will choose more clearly and particularly, for which research have stronger relationship with my topic.
     Finally, I am reminded of the correct writing style, including the right topic and the citation and reference again. As a punishment, professor said that there would be decrease of my points due to such writing errors. I will pay more attention on those mistakes, try not to make the same again.